Windfarms and Danger - Things do go wrong with turbines
On this page Turbine Failure Ice Throw Projectiles Vibration Other Dangers Operators Response Real Experiences
Read more health & safety issues?
Health & Safety Noise Shadow Flicker Shadow Flicker Maps More Turbine Failures The Argument for a 2K Setback Conisholme Disaster
A 2 kilometer buffer zone is essential to protect people and their homes
There are dangers to your Health from the continual daily operation of the turbines and from mechanical failure of these enormous industrial installations
Turbine manufacturers advise construction workers to live OVER 400 METRES from turbines
Turbine Failure
Wind turbines are major industrial installations
Wind turbines have major mechanical, electrical and electronic components
All these components can fail
Wind turbines do catch fire - this happened to one at Nissan, Sunderland
Turbines can break
The turbines are not supposed to operate above a certain wind speed - is this dependent on electronic sensing equipment that can fail and is monitored by a remote control centre?
The trend in turbine accident statistics shows that the number of accidents per year is increasing - the more turbines, the more accidents
   
Real Experiences
Conisholme in E Lincs in Jan 2009 - an example of a catastrophic failure of a wind turbine on a cold icy night.
Wind Turbine Disaaster in Denmark - a video of a turbine collapsing
The Caithness Campaign has collected statistics from windfarm accidents
Higashidorimura Japan turbine collapses
See images of turbine disasters from Richard Dow's blog " An English Guy"
   
Ice Throw
Ice builds up on the blades of the turbines and is then thrown off
Although the blades seem to be turning slowly, the tips are going at a speed in excess of 180mph. That will throw ice a long way
Ice Throw at Whittlesey Daily Telegraph (Peterborough) December 2008 - 2ft lumps of ice thrown off the blades
Wind Watch reports on Whittlesey ice throw
Ice Throw Video shows how ice builds up on the blades
   
Turbine Projectiles
A projectile from a turbine is any object that is thrown from the spinning blades
Projectiles could be ice throw or pieces of turbine or blades
Research shows that projectiles could land over 800 m from the turbine
That would cover most of Appleton Wiske
These projectiles could be pieces of metal and could be LETHAL
   
Vibration
Many of our village homes are extremely old (over 300 years) and were built without foundations
Vibration through the ground will be created
during the construction of the turbines
Transporting the enormous components past
our homes will cause vibration
Operation of the turbines will cause continual
daily vibration
Vibration is propogated through the ground
It cannot be predicted because the bedrock/ground
formation is unique in each site
Jane Davies from Deeping St Nicholas in S Lincs has had the vibraion is her home measured and confirmed. Her home is over 900 metres away fro the nearest turbine. Most of Appleton Wiske would be less than that
   
Searsburg, Germany
Other Dangers
It is difficult to find out about wind turbine accidents
The data is collected by the BWEA but is not available to the public
Police have blamed several road traffic accidents on distraction by wind turbines
The Caithness Campaign has collected statistics from windfarm accidents
   
Operators Response to Problems
What will happen if there is a problem with a turbine?
It is unlikely that there will be operator on site - especially at night
During the NHWAG visit to the Walkway windfarm, the engineer said he was responsible for x windfarms
Where will the control centre be?
Many of the operators are foreign ppower companies such as EDF
The control cenre may not be in the UK
How quick will the response be?
The response at Whittlesey after the ice throw was over 4 hours
It is very unlikely that there will be a dedicated engineer on site
The engineer at the nearby Walkway Windfarm looks after more than 10 windfarms
Related Information and Useful Lnks
HIGASHIDORIMURA, Japan

Japanese officials are investigating the safety of foreign-made wind turbines after a recent accident in Higashidorimura. A 223-foot generator on the wind farm in the Aomori Prefecture fell when the concrete base cracked, The Daily Yomiuri reported. The steel rods that were meant to support it and secure it to the base were left. Officials said the reason for the crash was still unknown but it was not likely the fall was caused by strong winds. It's designed to hold up in winds up to 134 mph, which is a high-rise building standard applied to wind turbines.
Forest Fires in Spain

Caused by a turbine fire
In February 2008, a 10-year-old Vestas turbine with a total height of less than 200 feet broke apart in a storm. Large pieces of the blades flew as far as 500 meters (1,640 feet) -- more than 8 times its total height
     
     
Appleton Wiske sponsors NHWAG